/ 開發 / By

VRP vs. TSP: Essence, Characteristics, Applications and Future Development

Route optimization is a critical issue in fields such as logistics, supply chain management, and intelligent transportation systems. Among the most representative mathematical models are the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) and the Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP). Although closely related, these two models differ significantly in their application scenarios and solution approaches. Despite the high market demand for route optimization, there are few true SaaS products available. This is largely due to the computational complexity of these problems and the unique requirements of individual enterprises. This article will delve into the nature, characteristics, and application scenarios of TSP and VRP, while also exploring future developments and possibilities for technological integration.

The Essence and Characteristics of the TSP (Traveling Salesman Problem)

The Traveling Salesperson (TSP) problem is a cornerstone of route optimization. Its definition is: “A salesperson needs to visit a series of cities, each city only once, and ultimately return to the starting point. Find the path that minimizes the total distance traveled.” The TSP is NP-complete, meaning that the solution time increases exponentially as the problem size increases.

Characteristics of TSP

  1. Single mobile body: only consider the shortest tour path of a single salesperson (or vehicle).
  2. No additional restrictions: No additional conditions such as vehicle load, time windows, service restrictions, etc. are considered.
  3. Minimum cost: The core objective is to minimize the total travel distance.
  4. NP-complete: Even with the best algorithms, the computational requirements for solving the problem rise dramatically as the number of cities increases.

Application Scenarios of TSP

  1. Smart Manufacturing: Optimizing the movement sequence of automated robotic arms.
  2. Gene sequencing: Similarity calculations applied to DNA sequence alignment.
  3. Patrol and monitoring: such as patrol robots and unmanned vehicle monitoring tasks to arrange the shortest path.

The Nature and Characteristics of VRP (Vehicle Routing Problem)

Vehicle Planning (VRP) is an extension of the Transport Planner (TSP) model, which considers the delivery problem of multiple vehicles. The goal is to plan the optimal route to minimize transportation costs while satisfying various constraints (such as load capacity and time windows).

Characteristics of VRP

  1. Multi-mobile: A delivery arrangement involving multiple vehicles.
  2. Subject to various constraints: including vehicle capacity, time windows, pickup and delivery pairing, priority levels, etc.
  3. Overall optimization: Unlike TSP’s single path optimization, VRP focuses on minimizing the cost of the entire system.
  4. Highly complex: There are many VRP variants, including Capacitated VRP (CVRP), Time Window VRP (VRPTW), and Pickup & Delivery VRP (PDVRP).
  5. NP-hard: More difficult to solve than NP-complete.
  1. E-commerce logistics: delivery optimization for Amazon, UPS, FedEx, etc.
  2. Food and medical delivery: Time windows and temperature control requirements must be considered.
  3. Shared Transportation: Optimize ride-sharing vehicle dispatch for Uber and Lyft.
  4. Smart cities and environmental protection: For example, optimizing garbage truck routes to reduce carbon emissions.

Application Scenarios of VRP

Why are Route Optimization SaaS products so rare in the market?

Although TSP and VRP have huge application potential, there are few dedicated SaaS solutions on the market. The main reasons are:

Highly customized requirements

Different industries and companies have different needs for route planning. From logistics distribution, express delivery services to shared transportation, each case has unique business logic and limitations. A single SaaS is unlikely to meet all needs.

Computationally expensive

TSP and VRP are NP-class problems, requiring extremely high computational requirements when solving them on a large scale. Despite the existence of heuristic algorithms (such as genetic algorithms, ant algorithms, and Tabu Search), computational costs remain a significant challenge for real-time SaaS. Software companies capable of challenging NP-class problems are relatively rare.

In conclusion

TSP and VRP are core mathematical problems in the field of route optimization, with wide applications in logistics, smart cities, and the sharing economy. However, due to their high computational complexity and the highly customized needs of enterprises, there are currently few SaaS products on the market that can provide general solutions to these problems. In the future, with advancements in AI, quantum computing, IoT, and autonomous driving technologies, the applications of VRP and TSP are expected to expand significantly, potentially driving a new wave of route optimization SaaS solutions.